One night, before heading to a Broadway show, Steve and I stopped by See No Evil, a tiny pizza restaurant tucked away below street level, inside the 50th Street subway …
BIG SALE - Up to 50% off food & beverage items - Free shipping on orders over $65
New York City: See No Evil – Pizza at the Subway Station
One night, before heading to a Broadway show, Steve and I stopped by See No Evil, a tiny pizza restaurant tucked away below street level, inside the 50th Street subway station. There’s a sign by the stairs, but if you’re not looking for it, you’ll likely walk right past. It feels a little like stumbling upon a speakeasy—if speakeasies served really good pizza and arancini instead of cocktails.
The place is small with low ceilings and cozy in a loud New York City kind of way. Tables are packed close together, and from every seat you’ve got a full view into the open kitchen. I always find it reassuring to see that the food is actually being made from scratch—and it smelled amazing in there.
I’m pretty sure we ordered arancini to start, though I can’t find any photos on my phone, so I might have dreamt that part. What I do know is that we ordered two pizzas:
FUNGHI – mushrooms, panna, roasted garlic, Parmigiano, fontina, arugula, lemon
HELL PIE – sauce, hot soppressata, pepperoni, smoked mozzarella, pecorino, Calabrian chili
The pizzas were really good. They were flavorful and clearly made with quality ingredients. The Hell Pie was my favorite. The staff warned us it was spicy, but to me the heat level was just perfect. Steve preferred the Funghi, which was more mellow, though slightly heavy on the arugula topping if you ask me.
Size-wise, the pizzas were on the smaller side, and both of us thought the crust-to-topping ratio leaned a little too heavy on the crust. Especially the Funghi, which had Steve stacking a little mountain of pizza crust on the side of his plate (he doesn’t eat crust).
So, is See No Evil worth it? The setting is fun, and the subway location makes it feel like a secret. Prices are a bit steep (our pizzas were $27 and $29), but hey, it’s Midtown Manhattan. While I wouldn’t call it a must-go, it’s definitely worth a visit—especially if you’re already in the area and up for a slice of underground pizza culture. Literally.
I found out after our visit that their soft-serve dessert with olive oil and salt is a thing—would’ve loved to try that! So yes, I guess there’ll be a next time.
See No Evil, 210 W 50th St Concourse #1, New York, NY 10019, United States
Book your hotel in New York City
There’s nothing like starting your day in New York City, with endless adventures waiting just outside your door. To get the best rates and the widest selection of hotels, I recommend booking well in advance of your stay.
Find the perfect place to call home while you're here:
I earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Welcome to Mitzie Mee - My blog about food, travel, and everything New York City.
New York City Blog
-
-
I was invited to the Grand Opening of the Ess-a-Bagel FiDi location as a guest. All opinions are my own (and Steve’s, for this particular post) If you ever wondered …
-
Last weekend, the weather was absolutely amazing in New York City, so we ended up going for a picnic in Central Park both Friday and Saturday. When you’re planning a …
-
Dirt Candy is one of the most interesting vegetarian restaurants I’ve been to. The food isn’t just plant-based—it’s beautiful, creative, and genuinely delicious. I had been for brunch back when …
-
For years, I’ve been complaining about the lack of good Danish casual restaurants in NYC. Yes, there are a few places serving Nordic food, but they tend to lean more …
-
(Disclaimer: I was invited to try some of the desserts at Matcha Cafe Maiko, but as always, opinions are my own.) Matcha Cafe Maiko is a cafe chain specializing in …
-
Disclaimer: I was invited to try Kajiken in New York City, but as always, all opinions in this post are my own. If you love ramen but haven’t tried abura …
-
Ras Plant Based is an Ethiopian restaurant in West Village, serving plant-based dishes rooted in traditional flavors with a modern twist. We started with the Injera Nachos—crispy injera chips topped …
-
The Orchid Show is an annual event at the New York Botanical Garden (NYBG) located in the Bronx. Spanning approximately 250 acres, it’s one of the largest and most renowned …
-
North Dumpling has been among my favorite places for cheap dumplings for years. It was my friend Alex, who introduced me to the tiny shop on Essex St. on our …
-
Woorijip is a Korean food spot located on 32nd street, right in the heart of Koreatown. It’s a great place for grab-and-go Korean comfort food with shelves filled with pre-packed …
-
I usually fly out of JFK late at night, squeezing every last minute out of my time in the city. But a morning flight to Phoenix last year meant that …
-
If you’re flying out of JFK’s Terminal 4, there’s a good chance you’ll find me relaxing at the Delta Sky Club near Gate B31. It’s not the flashiest lounge out …
-
Steve and I were both feeling a little under the weather, so I started browsing for some comforting stew or soup options for home delivery. After having tofu stew at …
-
Disclaimer: I was invited as a guest to Seoul Bap for this blog post. While the food was complimentary, all opinions expressed are my own and reflect my honest experience. …
-
The Rockefeller Center Christmas tree in New York City is one of the most iconic holiday symbols in the world, and each year, it draws millions of visitors. There’s a …
-
Disclaimer: I was invited as a guest to Ambo for this review. While the food was complimentary, all opinions expressed are my own and reflect my honest experience. Ambo is …
-
Disclaimer: I was invited as a guest to R Slice for this review. While the pizza was complimentary, all opinions expressed are my own and reflect my honest experience. Roberta’s …
Travel Blog
Mitzie Mee©
hello@mitziemee.com