NYC: How to eat a pizza slice like a real New Yorker

How to eat a pizza slice like a true New Yorker

When Steve and I had just started dating, we went out for pizza in New York City. I grabbed a slice, moved it over to my plate, and reached for my knife and fork. But before I could even cut into it, I heard a loud “Nooo!” from across the table. Rule number one: You do not eat pizza with a knife and fork in New York City. You use your hands. Always.

It took me a while to get the technique down, but I’ve mastered it now. And yes, there’s a proper way to do it. New York slices are big, thin, and often a little floppy in the middle. If you just grab one and lift it flat, you risk losing half the cheese on the way to your mouth.

Here’s the move: Gently fold the slice lengthwise by pressing down right at the crust. Just enough to form a soft V-shape. This helps hold everything in place, makes it easier to bite into, and keeps your hands relatively clean. That way, you can eat your slice while standing on the sidewalk or walking down the street, like a real New Yorker.

My guide to pizza in New York City

My guide to food and restaurants in New York City

Book your hotel in New York City

There’s nothing like starting your day in New York City, with endless adventures waiting just outside your door. To get the best rates and the widest selection of hotels, I recommend booking well in advance of your stay.

Find the perfect place to call home while you're here:

I earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Let's keep in touch!

Want to know what’s going on behind the scenes? My weekly newsletter is where I share a more personal side of my life — the trips I'm planning, the recipes I'm cooking, and the everyday moments that don’t always make it to the blog. If you’d like to stay in the loop and get a first look at what’s happening behind the scenes at Mitzie Mee, I’d love for you to join. Just sign up below — I’ll save you a seat.

I don’t spam! Read my privacy policy for more info.

Mitzie Mee - Sanne

Hi, I'm Sanne and this is my blog about food & travel.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages

New York City Blog

Ninja Air Fryer 4-in-1 Pro
$99.99

I’ve had really good experiences with the Ninja air fryers. They're easy to use, the quality feels solid, and the results are consistently great. I’ve had really good experiences with the Ninja air fryers. They’re easy to use, the quality feels solid, and the results are consistently great. I like that you don’t have to fuss around with settings to get good food out of it. Vegetables turn out crisp without drying out, and chicken comes out juicy with a nice golden crust. It’s one of those kitchen gadgets that actually lives up to the hype and ends up being used all the time.

I earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/09/2025 04:00 pm GMT
Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker
$199.95

The Ninja CREAMi is hands down the best ice cream maker I’ve tried. What I really like is the texture. The ice cream comes out so smooth and creamy, better than anything I’ve managed with other machines. It’s also incredibly easy to use: you prep your base, freeze it overnight, and then let the CREAMi do the rest. With several one-touch programs, you can make ice cream, sorbet, gelato, milkshakes, or even smoothie bowls, and the re-spin function lets you make your batch softer if you prefer. You can go all in with decadent gelato, or make lighter, low-sugar or dairy-free versions. You can even add your favorite mix-ins like chocolate, nuts, or fruit to make it your own. It’s a fun, reliable machine that makes experimenting with flavors at home so much more exciting.

I earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/09/2025 04:00 pm GMT