Every Friday, Whole Foods has a special oyster deal, $12 for 12 oysters for Prime members. You can mix and match, try different kinds, and at most stores they’ll shuck them for you and pack everything on ice so you’re all set to take them home.
Last time I went, there was a long line at the seafood counter, so after placing my order, I was told to come back later to pick them up, which is pretty standard when it’s busy. The shucking tends to be a bit rushed, so I always go through the oysters before serving and remove any tiny bits of shell.
The special deal is only on for Fridays. If you go on any other day, or if you don’t have Prime, you’ll pay around $2 per oyster, which is more or less what you’d pay at happy hour specials at bars and restaurants around the city. Still a good deal, especially since you get to enjoy them at home with your choice of wine, music, and lighting.
I would usually serve the oysters with mignonette and a slice of lemon. Mignonette is one of those simple sauces that makes oysters taste even more like oysters, if that makes sense. The vinegar sharpens the flavor, the shallots add a little bite, and the pepper ties it all together. Here’s my recipe if you want to give it a try:
Recipe: Mignonette Sauce for Oysters
